Florida tomato growers mistreat migrant labor, U.S.
senators argue
By WILLIAM E. GIBSON
Washington Bureau Chief Sun-Sentinel
April 16, 2008
WASHINGTON
Citing evidence of "modern-day slavery"
and abuse in South Florida's tomato fields, a Senate committee pressed
growers on Tuesday to raise the pay of migrant workers and improve their
living conditions.
Sen. Ted Kennedy of Massachusetts and three fellow Democratic senators
called the conditions for migrant workers on South Florida farms
"shameful" and an example of how the nation has neglected people who
toil for low pay in backbending jobs while trapped in substandard
housing.
Consumers would be shocked at the working conditions of people who
harvest Florida tomatoes, members of the Senate committee on labor said
at a hearing Tuesday.
"Their working conditions are deplorable, but most of them are afraid to
demand fair treatment because they know they'll be fired, blacklisted or
turned over to immigration officials," said Kennedy, the committee
chairman.
A Collier County sheriff's investigator and other witnesses cited
instances of tomato pickers being slapped or beaten, locked into tiny
trailers, chained to a wooden post, held behind barbed-wire fences and
forced to work to pay off debts for food and housing.
"At the rate they are paid, it's hard for them to ever get out of that
debt cycle," Detective Charlie Frost said. "If they decide to leave or
want more money, then there's the threat of violence."
The Coalition of Immokalee Workers and other critics call such
conditions "modern-day slavery."
The senators were disturbed that growers had resisted an offer by
McDonald's and other major food chains to pay an extra penny a pound for
Florida tomatoes to boost worker pay. The Florida Tomato Growers
Exchange, an industry group based in Maitland, threatens to impose
$100,000 fines on growers who accept the offer.
Reggie Brown, executive vice president of the exchange, told the
committee his group does not oppose attempts to help workers, but it
does not want growers to distribute the additional penny per pound. He
said participation could lead to charges under a racketeering law
because it would be impossible to fairly sort out how much extra pay to
give each worker.
Brown said the industry strongly opposes forced labor and has taken
"progressive steps" to prevent abuses by labor contractors. He said
growers provide competitive wages, which are based on the number of
tomatoes picked, that amount to nearly double Florida's minimum wage of
$6.79 per hour to the more than 30,000 workers during harvesting season.
Higher wages could leave growers unable to compete against cheap imports
from Mexico, he said.
"We believe that ultimately fast-food chains and other companies will
buy tomatoes elsewhere, most likely Mexico," Brown told the committee.
"If that business shifts offshore, not only will tomato harvesters be
without the extra penny, they will be without jobs."
The senators, who said workers cannot possibly pick enough tomatoes in
an hour to come close to $12, were not swayed.
"If Florida tomato growers can't live with workers being paid a penny a
pound more, then I can live without tomatoes from Florida on my
hamburger," said Sen. Richard Durbin, D-Ill. "And I think most Americans
would say the same."
Sen. Bernie Sanders, an Independent from Vermont, said he will request
an investigation into wages and working conditions in the tomato fields
by the Government Accountability Office, the research arm of Congress.
"Some might say, 'This is a local Immokalee issue, it is a Florida
issue.' No, it's not," said Sanders, who visited Immokalee in January.
"In America today, we have a race to the bottom. What I saw in Immokalee
is the bottom. And if we do not lift that bottom up, every worker in
America is in danger."
He also indicated the committee would try to broaden labor laws to cover
migrant workers.
"We're not letting up," Kennedy said. "We want everybody to know,
particularly the growers, that we're staying on this."